You are being invited to take part in a research study called ‘The Complex Emotions Research Study’. We want to learn more about what influences these emotions and how to improve support and treatments available.These complex emotions experienced may or may not be linked to diagnoses such as Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD), Emotional Unstable Personality Disorder (EUPD) and Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (CPTSD). We understand that these terms can be stigmatising, so we have chosen to use the term complex emotions instead. The study is led by the University of Sheffield and the University of Plymouth.
This study is being organised by Professor Scott Weich and the research is part of a wider Mental Health Research Platform funded by UK Research & Innovation (UKRI). The platform includes six research hubs across the UK, all focused on better understanding severe mental health conditions.
The study proposal has been reviewed by:
An independent panel of experts at UKRI as part of the funding process.
People with lived experience of mental health conditions, who have provided feedback on the study design and ethics as part of the Lived Experience Advisory Panel.
An independent NHS Research Ethics Committee (insert REC name) that has given a XXX ethical opinion.
NHS Management Approval has also been XXX
By complex emotions we mean feelings that can be overwhelming, unpredictable, or hard to control. Some people describe feeling too much or sometimes nothing at all. These can be hard to manage, and often centre around difficulties with relationships, emotional regulation, impulsive and harmful behaviour.
These problems are often linked to diagnosis such as Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD), Emotionally Unstable Personality Disorder (EUPD), Complex Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (CPTSD); as well as other diagnosis such as Depression and Anxiety, Autism, and Emotional Dysregulation. Some people who experience complex emotions may have one or more of these diagnoses; others will have no official diagnosis at all. Our research is not limited by diagnosis. We understand that labels can be stigmatising and limiting, so we have chosen to use the term complex emotions instead.
You have been asked to take part because you are 16 or older; you have lived or worked in areas designated by Plymouth or Sheffield postcodes within the past 5 years (note that if a participant moves outside of this area during the course of the research they will be eligible to continue to take part); and you have one or more of the following difficulties with complex emotions:
● Challenges in creating and maintaining relationships
● Fears of abandonment
● Difficulties regulating emotions
● Intense emotions or feelings of detachment/dissociation
● Difficulties managing impulses, such as self-harm or suicidal thoughts
● Using substances like alcohol and drugs to numb these emotions.
We are looking to recruit a mixed group of participants, including those who are often missed from complex emotions research such as - men, older adults and people from ethnically diverse groups.
Please note, you do not need to have a formal diagnosis associated with complex emotions or be under specialist care to take part. However, participants must be comfortable reading and speaking English.
If you decide to take part, you will be given this information sheet to keep and you will be asked to complete a screening survey. You might get given this as a paper copy by someone in an organisation you use with a pre-paid envelope to post it back or you might get given a QR code to scan or a hyperlink which will take you to an electronic screening survey. We have built in lots of ways to ask questions before and during the research project such as a dedicated email.
● Screening Survey: 20 minutes | online
You will be asked about your complex emotions and for some basic personal information (like your age, gender and contact details). This will clarify whether you are eligible to take part in our study and allow us to contact you. This information is used for screening, not research purposes.
After that, your journey will look a bit like the map below. The research is planned to last for three years.
Figure 1: Participants research journey visual
● Baseline Interview and baseline measures
60 minutes + | in-person or online video call (camera must be switched on for this)
If you are eligible to take part in the study then one of our researchers will contact you with more information and consent forms which you will need to have time to consider and sign (if you are happy to) before taking part in the baseline interview. The Interview will be with one of our researchers. This interview is using a diagnostic interview tool for research purposes only, it will not give you any diagnosis. It helps the research team get to know you and how your complex emotions impact you.
This stage also includes a set of self report questionnaires, these will look at very specific symptoms and areas we are interested in exploring. You can complete these during or after the interview. We will thank you for your time by sending you a gift voucher worth £30.
● Repeat Surveys
45 minutes | every six months | online or via video call
These surveys will be sent to you every six months via an online survey or telephone/video call if you prefer. They will ask about your complex emotions, mental and physical health and social environment. We will thank you for your time by sending you a gift voucher worth £10 for each returned survey. Depending on when people join this study the maximum number of repeat surveys you will be sent, would be five.
● Optional Sub-Studies
We are also asking permission to contact you about additional studies linked to this one. These could be:
○ Interviews exploring specific experiences;
○ Using smartphones/watches to record emotions and experiences in real time;
○ Co-designing and testing support interventions for example.
We will send you information about what each study involves so you can decide if you want to take part, and there will be separate consent forms for each of them. Taking part in the main study does not mean you have to participate in any of the sub-studies.
If you are eligible after the screening survey - We are offering vouchers to thank you for your time and engagement with the project. These can be spent with a wide range of retailers online and in-store, but cannot be exchanged for cash or alternatives. We will also cover any local travel expenses (although in-person attendance is not an essential part of the study).
As part of this research study, we will collect some identifiable information (e.g., your name, contact details, and relevant medical conditions). This is needed to stay in touch with you and to support our analysis.
We will collect data on:
Your basic demographics: Age, gender, ethnicity, housing, and employment.
Your complex emotions: Symptoms and their impact on daily life. We will also ask about trauma experiences, self harm and suicidal thoughts.
Your wider mental health: Including co-occurring challenges, medications, diagnoses and services you access
Your physical health: To better understand its relationship with complex emotions.
As part of the interviews will be collecting your stories of how this has impacted you and your life as well as your experiences of support and services.
All the information we collect during the course of the research will be kept confidential and there are strict laws which safeguard your privacy at every stage. During analysis, all personal details will be replaced with a unique number, and any published results will not include information that could identify you. If quotes from your interviews are used in the research, they will be anonymised. However, it is possible you may recognise your own words. If you tell us anything that puts you or someone else in danger/harm then we may have to break confidentiality, but we will let you know if this happens.
GP Notification: We will inform your GP that you are taking part in this study. However, no data collected during the study will be shared with them unless you request it.
We aim to be as paperless as possible, any identifiable information collected from you during this study will be stored securely on online servers managed by Sheffield and Plymouth University; (such as the University of Sheffield data storage service Xdrive). Access to this data will be limited to members of the research team who need to access it.
Your data will be anonymised by assigning a code number instead of using your name for all analysis and publication purposes. Any personal information collected on paper will be kept secure in locked cabinets within locked offices at the University of Sheffield and University of Plymouth (ADD ADDRESSES).
Collaborators on the research project may access your data, but any sharing with third parties will be covered by strict data sharing agreements to ensure your information is protected. Once the study is complete, we will retain some data to verify the results. It will be stored for 15 years after the study ends, after which it will be securely deleted. Reports and publications will not contain any information that could identify you.
You will be given the options on the consent form for your anonymised data (data that does not include any personal information such as your name, DOB, Address) to also be shared with:
DATAMIND - This is one of the mental health research hubs also funded by the UKRI. They are developing a mental health data repository (this is a virtual place where anonymised data collected in different mental health research projects is stored and can be used in future by researchers or industry partners). Your anonymised data could be used in DATAMIND's (or industry partners') future research.
Researchers in the wider UKRI Mental Health Platform for additional cross analysis. The Mental Health Platform will store data for up to 15 years after the study ends for use in future, ethically approved research.
Additionally, analyses may be conducted by commercial providers, but no personal information will ever be shared with these providers.
The results of the research and the diagnostic tools used are for research purposes only and have not been validated for diagnosis or clinical care. This means they will not be shared with your GP or treating clinical team.
Results from this study will be shared as social media posts and reported to local and national news. We aim to publish the findings in scientific journal articles. We will also aim to present our findings at scientific conferences as well as regularly updating our research study website with bulletins and newsletters of our progress and findings. You will not be identifiable in any published results. Participants will also be able to access the results through the study website.
No, taking part is entirely your choice.If you choose not to take part, or if you decide to withdraw at any stage, please contact one of the researchers involved in the study. However, you do not need to give a reason. Your decision will not affect your medical care or your legal rights in any way.
If you do decide to take part, you will be given this information sheet to keep and will be asked to sign a consent form. You will have lots of chances to ask questions, such as via email, phone or before any data collection such as at the start of any interview.
You can withdraw from the study at any point without giving a reason. If you decide to withdraw from the study, you will have the option to:
Withdraw from all aspects of the study, but allow us to continue to analyse the data collected from you up to that point; or
Withdraw from all aspects of the study, and withdraw all of the data collected from you up to that point from any analysis.
Once the study has ended, it will no longer be possible for you to withdraw your data.
Unfortunately there might be a number of reasons why you can’t take part.
If you live outside of the recruitment area or have no connection to the recruitment area - we are only funded to explore this research question in the Plymouth and Sheffield regions.
If you are unable to comfortably speak or read English.
If you don't meet inclusion criteria of experiencing symptoms associated with difficulties with complex emotions.
It might mean this is not the right study for you.
We hope that the information you provide will help us to develop more effective approaches to clinical care and treatments in the future for people who experience complex emotions.
While it is unlikely that you will experience direct benefits from taking part in the study in terms of treatment or understanding your health, participating in research can be a positive and empowering experience. It provides a potential opportunity to share your experiences and tell your story in a meaningful way.
Additionally, the research team will send you regular newsletters and updates about the study. These will include information on what we are doing, key findings, and useful resources. These updates will be co-written with our Lived Experience Advisory Panel, a group of over 10 people with lived experience who are actively helping us design and review all our materials. The findings from this study could contribute to improving the care and support available to people with complex emotional challenges in the future.
There are some possible risks associated with taking part in this study, which are outlined below. Although every effort will be made to minimise or eliminate these risks, it is important that you understand them so you can make an informed decision about whether this is the right study and time for you to be involved.
If any of the following risks affect you, please remember that you can take a break, pause, or withdraw from the study at any time.
Long time frame: This study spans approx 3 years, which may feel like a significant commitment. You will have the flexibility to take breaks if needed.
Triggering questions: Many of the surveys and interview topics used in this study will ask about sensitive topics, including trauma, self-harm and suicide, which may be triggering. We fully appreciate the role that trauma can play in complex emotions and with this in mind we will only ask you to respond to questions you feel comfortable with. At any point during your survey or interview(s), you can pause, take a break, or withdraw from the study. You can bring someone to support you to the interviews.
Stigma: We recognise that complex emotions are not limited to specific medical diagnoses. However, for some participants, these associated diagnoses (e.g. BPD, CPTSD, or EUPD) may carry negative stigma. Please be assured that the information you share with us and your involvement in this study will remain confidential. All data will be securely stored on encrypted university servers, and any published results will be anonymised to ensure your privacy.
Not being selected for sub-studies: Some of our sub-studies have limits on the number of participants, such as 40 for the interview sub-study and 50 for the smartwatch sub-study. Unfortunately, we cannot change these caps, which means not everyone who expresses an interest in a sub-study will be selected. We understand that this may be disappointing, and we want to emphasise how much we value and appreciate your interest and involvement. We will communicate selection decisions in a timely and sensitive manner. Details about selection criteria will be provided in the participant information sheets for each sub-study.
It is important to note that while we assure complete confidentiality, this may have to be broken if a participant appears to be at serious risk of harm to themselves or other people.
This is a research study and we are unable to offer therapy or treatment as part of our research study. However we do want to support you in being a research participant. During your baseline interview you will be told who your named contact will be whilst you are a participant; your named contact will be one of the members of the research team. They will contact you on your preferred method of contact (such as phone, text or email) to check in with you every 6 months and remind you when a data collect point is due or to invite you to sub studies. They will also be your main point of call if you have a question, query or comment about the research and the research process. They will only be contactable during office hours 9am - 5pm Monday - Friday - they will try and get back to you within two working days. This is not a crisis line. We can only signpost to other services available or to your health care team. During your initial interview we will ask for an emergency contact detail and your GP details, We would only contact these and emergency services if a safeguarding issue was flagged with a threat to life (self or others).
If you find yourself becoming upset or distressed or share information , is there anything that we can do that will help you'? Telephone numbers for participants support network, signposting - a mini plan of action for each individual participant?
If you have a question or concern about any aspect of this study, please contact the study team at: complex_emotions_hub@sheffield.ac.uk who will do their best to answer your questions.
In the unlikely event that something goes wrong and you are harmed during the research and this is due to someone’s negligence then you may have grounds for a legal action for compensation against NHS [XXXX] but you may have to pay your legal costs. The normal National Health Service complaints mechanisms will still be available to you (if appropriate).
If you would like to discuss this study with someone independent of the study please contact <insert contact details>.
If you wish to make a complaint about the study please contact:
Patient Experience Team
University of Sheffield/Plymouth contact details
SHSC
PI - Scott Weich
Thank you
This is an important project that hopes to explore, transform and improve the landscape of care for people who struggle with complex emotions. We highly appreciate you taking the time to read this information sheet and hope that you have found it interesting and clear.